Your roof is one of the most important features of your home. It protects you from rain, snow, heat, and other elements. While you may not see or think about your roof every day, it plays a crucial role in safeguarding your home. When it's time to replace your roof, you'll need to decide which material and style makes the most sense for your needs, budget, and architectural style.
The experts at www.greenmanroofing.com have been installing top-quality roofs on homes in our area for over 30 years, so we wanted to provide a helpful overview of some pros and cons of popular roofing options to consider as you make this key decision.
Asphalt Shingles
Asphalt shingles are the most common roofing material in the United States. They're affordable, easy to install, come in a variety of styles and colors, last 20-30 years on average, and provide decent protection.
Pros:
- Inexpensive compared to other roofing materials
- Easy installation and repairs
- Wide variety of shingle styles, textures, and colors
- Durable in many weather conditions
Cons:
- Shorter lifespan than other materials like metal or tile
- Vulnerable in severe storms with high winds or large hail
- Can deteriorate faster in very hot, sunny climates
- Not as aesthetically pleasing for some homeowners
While basic 3-tab asphalt shingles are most budget-friendly, there are architectural and luxury shingles that emulate slate, wood shake, and other high-end looks if desired.
Metal Roofing
Once used mostly for agricultural and industrial buildings, metal roofs are gaining popularity for modern homes today. They're extremely durable, energy efficient, and eye catching.
Pros:
- Very long lifespan - 50+ years
- Reflective nature helps reduce energy costs
- Withstands extreme weather like hail storms
- Variety of styles from traditional to modern
- Requires little maintenance
Cons:
- Higher upfront cost to purchase and install
- Rain/hail can be noisy during storms
- Care is needed when installing to avoid leaks
- Some homeowners associations don't allow
- Can require additional framing support
If installed correctly and with quality materials, metal roofs require very little long term upkeep while protecting your home for decades. Their sleek look offers great curb appeal too.
Wood Shakes and Shingles
Nothing looks more classic and natural on a home than real wood roofing. Cedar and redwood are most common because they have natural oils that help repel water and insulate better.
Pros:
- Beautiful, warm aesthetic for many home styles
- Can last 30-50 years when properly maintained
- Good options for complex roof shapes and angles
- Versatile - can stain or treat for unique looks
Cons:
- Among the most expensive roofing materials
- Require thorough fireproofing treatment
- Susceptible to mold, moss growth without care
- Frequent maintenance needed to maximize lifespan
- Prone to lifting, cracking, and leaks as they age
Wood looks wonderful but requires more hands on care and vigilance than most other roofing to stay in good shape. Be prepared for higher long term costs too.
Tile Roofing
Clay and concrete tiles roofing lend a very distinctive, dramatic look on many Mediterranean, Spanish colonial, and southwestern architectural styles.
Pros:
- Long lifespan - 50+ years
- Great natural curb appeal
- Excellent fire, wind, and rain/hail resistance
- Cooler than asphalt in hot climates
- Popular for unique architectural styles
Cons:
- Heavier than other roofing, requiring reinforced framing
- Higher upfront installation cost
- Can crack or break if walked on or impacted
- Low pitch can allow leaks if not installed perfectly
- Snow and debris can slide off more easily
Tile costs more initially but lasts beautifully for decades. It pairs wonderfully with stucco and stone exteriors. Just be sure your roof structure can handle the weight load properly.
Choosing What's Best for Your Home and Budget
There are pros, cons, and key considerations for any type of roofing material you may choose. As you consider options for your replacement or new construction roof, involve a professional early on to help select durable products that enhance your home's style and stay within your budget.
